ragdoll vs birman

Two soft, blue-eyed, pointed, semi-longhaired charmers, both gentle, both devoted, both easily muddled by anyone who has not lived with them. The Ragdoll and the Birman are the second most confused pair on the whole roster, and they are genuinely similar. But there are reliable ways to tell them apart, starting with size, a party trick, and a very specific detail about their paws.

size settles most cases

The simplest difference is scale. The Ragdoll is one of the largest domestic breeds, a big, heavy, substantial cat that keeps growing for years and ends up genuinely imposing. The Birman is a medium-sized cat, elegant and solid but nowhere near the Ragdoll's bulk. If the cat in question is enormous, you are almost certainly looking at a Ragdoll. If it is a graceful medium, lean Birman.

the flop, and the gloves

Two details clinch it. First, the flop: the Ragdoll is named for its habit of going completely limp and relaxed when you pick it up, melting into your arms like its namesake toy. The Birman does not do this, and stays a normal, self-respecting cat when lifted. Second, and most reliable of all, look at the paws. The Birman has four pure white paws, its famous white gloves, symmetrical and neat, as if it stepped in paint, and this is a defining, consistent feature of the breed. Ragdolls come in several patterns, and while the mitted variety has white paws too, the Birman's gloves are its signature. When in doubt, check the feet and see if the cat flops.

coat and temperament

Both wear a soft, silky, semi-long coat with little of the matting a true longhair suffers, and both are pointed, with darker faces, ears, legs and tails against a paler body. Temperament is where they are most alike: both are famously gentle, docile, people-loving cats that follow you about and settle happily on a lap. If anything the Ragdoll is the more placid and floppy, the Birman a touch more playful and lively, but both are calm, affectionate companions well suited to a quiet, loving home. You will be happy with either. The full write-ups live at ragdoll and birman.

and if it came from a shelter

As ever, the honest note. Both are pedigreed breeds, and a real Ragdoll or Birman comes with a breeder and papers. A soft, pointed, blue-eyed cat that arrived by other means is very likely a mixed-breed cat that happens to carry pointed colouring, which turns up widely thanks to Siamese ancestry in the general cat population. That does not make it any less lovely. Use the size, the flop and the gloves to make your best guess, and if the answer is a magnificent moggy, that is no loss at all.

Related reading from my desk: the ragdoll and birman profiles, and the most affectionate cat breeds, on which both of these place highly.

more from the journal